Utah does not legally enforce open adoption agreements through the court system in private adoptions, which means post-adoption contact agreements (PACAs) are not binding contracts that a judge can force adoptive parents to honor.

However, this doesn't mean open adoption is unreliable—it means success depends on choosing the right family and working with an agency like American Adoptions that actively supports these relationships long-term.

Below, we'll explain what open adoptions mean in Utah, how agreements work without legal enforcement, and how American Adoptions ensures your open adoption plan succeeds through relationship-building rather than court orders.

Are Open Adoptions Legally Enforceable in Utah?

The legal answer: No, Utah does not have laws making open adoption agreements legally enforceable for private adoptions.

What this means:

• Post-adoption contact agreements aren't binding contracts in Utah courts
• You cannot sue to enforce the agreement if adoptive parents stop contact
• Judges cannot order adoptive parents to maintain communication
• The agreement functions as a "good faith" understanding

What this doesn't mean:

• That open adoption is fake or unreliable
• That adoptive families routinely break agreements
• That you have no protection or recourse
• That you shouldn't pursue open adoption

The absence of legal enforcement doesn't make open adoption fail. Successful open adoptions depend on relationship quality, not court orders.

In states that do legally enforce these agreements, birth parents rarely use the courts to compel contact. Why? Because families usually want to do what is best for their child.

What matters more: Choosing a family who genuinely wants open adoption and working with an agency that actively supports the relationship.

Learn about open adoption benefits.

Open Adoption Agreements Explained: What They Mean for You

Even without legal enforceability in Utah, open adoption agreements are crucial documents outlining everyone's expectations.

A typical agreement includes:

Communication Frequency:

• How often you'll receive updates (weekly, monthly, quarterly, annually)
• Types of communication (photos, videos, letters, texts, emails)
• Who initiates contact and through what channels

Visit Arrangements:

• Frequency of in-person visits (if desired)
• Location preferences and settings
• Who attends and duration of visits

Boundaries and Expectations:

• Response timeframes for messages
• How to handle disagreements or life changes
• Plans for major milestones (birthdays, graduations)

At American Adoptions, every family commits to:

• Some degree of openness (from annual updates to regular visits)
• At least one in-person visit within the first 5 years
• Good-faith efforts to honor the agreement

Think of it as a relationship blueprint—both families want to honor it because they care about the child's wellbeing.

Explore finding open adoption families.

What Happens If an Open Adoption Agreement Is Broken?

While Utah law doesn't let you sue for enforcement, you're not powerless if contact stops.

What you can do:

1. Contact American Adoptions

In some cases we can help you:

• Understand what caused the breakdown
• Clarify misunderstandings
• Adjust expectations if circumstances changed
• Rebuild communication and trust

2. Understand Common Reasons Contact Stops

• Family crisis (illness, job loss, emergency)
• Child's developmental challenges requiring adjustment
• Miscommunication about expectations
• Life circumstances creating temporary barriers

3. Adjust the Agreement

Open adoption evolves—agreements may need updating:

• Different communication methods as your child grows
• Modified visit frequency due to practical constraints
• Temporary pauses during challenging times
• New boundaries based on everyone's needs

What you cannot do in Utah:

• Sue for breach of contract
• Force compliance through court orders
• Use broken agreements to reverse the adoption
• Regain custody because contact stopped

Learn about building lasting relationships.

How to Choose the Right Family in an Open Adoption

Since legal enforcement isn't available in Utah, choosing the right family becomes your greatest protection.

Green flags in adoptive families:

• They bring up open adoption enthusiastically, not reluctantly
• They have specific, realistic ideas about maintaining contact
• They understand open adoption benefits the child
• They ask about your preferences and needs
• They're willing to evolve the agreement over time

Red flags to watch for:

• Vague or reluctant about open adoption commitments
• Make promises that sound too good to be true
• Only talk about what they want, not what you need
• Can't explain why open adoption matters for the child

American Adoptions helps you:

• Review detailed family profiles showing openness levels
• Have direct conversations with potential families
• Gauge their sincerity and commitment
• Create clear, specific agreements before placement
• Feel confident in your match

Every family has been counseled on open adoption's importance and committed to honoring agreements before they're approved to adopt.

Browse families seeking open adoption.

The Role of American Adoptions in Your Open Adoption Journey

We don't just facilitate your initial agreement—we actively support your relationship indefinitely.

Before Placement:

• Help you articulate your openness preferences
• Match you with families committed to your vision
• Facilitate conversations to evaluate compatibility
• Draft clear, detailed agreements

After Placement:

• Check in with both families
• Support relationship evolution as your child grows

Ongoing Support:

• Counseling when you need it
• Connections to help for navigating major transitions
• Resources for maintaining healthy boundaries
• Support connecting when needed

Learn about trust in open adoption.

Why So Many Birth Parents Feel Open Adoption Is Right for Them

Benefits for Birth Parents:

• Ongoing peace of mind seeing your child thrive
• Easier grief processing through continued connection
• A meaningful role in your child's life
• No haunting "what ifs" or worst-case scenarios

Benefits for Your Child:

• Complete understanding of their story and origins
• Access to medical history and heritage
• Connection to birth family without conflicting loyalties
• Reduced anxiety and identity struggles

Explore the full benefits.

Real Stories: Open Adoption from a Birth Mother's Perspective

Start Your Open Adoption Journey with American Adoptions

You don't need Utah courts to enforce your agreement. What you need is:

• A family who genuinely values your role
• An agency supporting open adoption relationships long-term
• Ongoing support

American Adoptions provides all of this.

When you reach out, you'll:

• Speak with specialists who understand Utah adoption laws
• Learn how we screen families for openness
• Understand what level of contact you can expect
• Create an agreement reflecting your needs

You don't have to wonder if open adoption is reliable. You don't have to worry about families disappearing. You don't have to navigate this alone.

Call 1-800-ADOPTION or connect with open adoption families online and learn how open adoptions work in Utah—and how we ensure your relationship lasts through support, not court orders.

Disclaimer
Information available through these links is the sole property of the companies and organizations listed therein. American Adoptions provides this information as a courtesy and is in no way responsible for its content or accuracy.