If you're considering placing your baby for adoption in Arkansas, you might be wondering whether an open adoption agreement will hold up legally. It's a valid concern — after all, maintaining a connection with your child after placement is often one of the most important factors in your decision.

The good news is that Arkansas law does allow for post-adoption contact agreements (PACAs) between birth parents and adoptive families. However, these agreements aren't always enforceable in court the way a traditional contract would be. Understanding your rights and the role of your adoption agency can help you feel more confident as you move forward.

Get started with American Adoptions to learn how we support birth mothers in creating and maintaining meaningful relationships with adoptive families.

This guide will walk you through everything you need to know about open adoption agreements in Arkansas, what happens if contact is broken, and how American Adoptions can support you throughout your journey.

Are Open Adoptions Legally Enforceable in Arkansas?

Arkansas does recognize post-adoption contact agreements (PACAs) under state law. These agreements can be established before or after the adoption is finalized and may include provisions for letters, photos, phone calls, or in-person visits between birth parents and the child.

However, Arkansas courts do not treat PACAs as legally binding contracts in the traditional sense. That means if an adoptive family stops following the agreement, you generally cannot take them to court to force them to comply. According to Arkansas law, these agreements are considered "unenforceable" in most cases, meaning they function more as goodwill commitments rather than legal obligations.

That said, Arkansas law does allow for judicial enforcement in very limited circumstances — specifically, if the adoptive parents voluntarily agree to make the PACA enforceable as part of the adoption decree. Even then, enforcement is rare and typically only pursued if there's a significant breakdown in the relationship.

While this might sound discouraging, the reality is that most open adoptions work well because they're built on mutual respect and shared commitment — not court orders. American Adoptions has decades of experience facilitating healthy, lasting relationships between birth and adoptive families. We carefully screen families and help set realistic expectations from the start.

Open Adoption Agreements Explained: What They Mean for You

An open adoption agreement is a written plan that outlines how birth parents and adoptive parents will stay in contact after the adoption is finalized. These agreements are highly customizable and can include:

• Exchange of letters and photos through the agency
• Text messages or phone calls
• Video chats
• In-person visits on agreed-upon occasions

The level of openness varies from family to family. Some birth parents prefer semi-open arrangements where communication happens through the agency, while others prefer fully open relationships with direct contact.

At American Adoptions, we ask all of our adoptive families to commit to some level of openness and at least one in-person visit within the first five years of the child's life. This policy helps ensure that birth mothers have the opportunity to see their child grow and know they're thriving in a loving home.

It's important to understand that open adoption agreements are flexible. They can evolve over time based on the needs and comfort levels of everyone involved. For example, you might start with letters and photos and later move to video calls or visits as the relationship develops.

What Happens If an Open Adoption Agreement Is Broken?

One of the most common fears birth mothers have is, "What if the adoptive family stops communicating after placement?" While it's a valid concern, breaking contact is relatively uncommon when you work with a reputable agency like American Adoptions.

If an adoptive family does stop following the open adoption plan, there are a few options available:

Mediation through the agency: American Adoptions serves as a mediator and advocate for birth mothers. If communication breaks down, our team can step in to facilitate conversations, address concerns, and work toward a resolution. Often, misunderstandings can be cleared up with support and guidance from experienced adoption specialists.

Court petitions (rare): In Arkansas, birth parents typically cannot sue to enforce a PACA unless it was specifically made enforceable in the adoption decree. However, adoptive parents who repeatedly fail to honor the agreement may face reputational consequences, especially if they're working with an agency that values transparency and integrity.

Documentation and advocacy: Keeping records of all communications and agreed-upon plans can be helpful if disputes arise. While legal action may not be an option, agencies like American Adoptions prioritize ethical practices and will advocate on your behalf to maintain the relationship.

The best way to prevent contact from breaking down is to choose a family that genuinely values openness and to work with an agency that provides ongoing support. Talk to an adoption specialist about how we screen families and facilitate healthy, long-term relationships.

How to Choose the Right Family in an Open Adoption

One of the most empowering parts of the adoption process is choosing the family who will raise your child. At American Adoptions, you have complete control over this decision.

When you browse family profiles, you'll see detailed information about each family's lifestyle, values, parenting style, and openness preferences. Profiles often include photos, letters to expectant mothers, and videos that give you a sense of who they are.

Here's what to look for when selecting a family:

• Openness preferences: Make sure their desired level of contact aligns with yours. Some families are comfortable with frequent visits, while others prefer periodic updates.
• Shared values: Do their beliefs, parenting philosophies, and lifestyle resonate with you?
• Communication style: Pay attention to how they express themselves. Do they seem warm, genuine, and respectful?
• Support network: Families with strong support systems — grandparents, extended family, close friends — often have more resources to provide a stable, loving home.

Once you've selected a family, you'll have the opportunity to meet them, either in person or virtually. This meeting allows you to ask questions, share your hopes for the open adoption, and begin building a relationship. Many birth mothers find that this connection brings peace of mind and confidence in their decision. Learn more about finding open adoption families through American Adoptions.

The Role of American Adoptions in Your Open Adoption Journey

At American Adoptions, we understand that open adoption is about relationships, not contracts. Our role is to support you every step of the way — from finding the right family to facilitating communication after placement.

Here's how we help:

Careful family screening: We thoroughly vet all adoptive families to ensure they're financially stable, emotionally prepared, and genuinely committed to openness. We require families to agree to at least one in-person visit within the first five years, giving you peace of mind that contact will be maintained.

Personalized adoption plans: Your adoption plan is unique to your needs and preferences. We'll work with you to create an open adoption agreement that feels comfortable and realistic.

Ongoing mediation: If challenges arise after placement, we're here to facilitate communication and resolve conflicts. Our team has decades of experience helping birth and adoptive families maintain healthy, respectful relationships.

Lifetime support: Even after your adoption is finalized, we remain available to answer questions, provide resources, and offer emotional support through our post-placement services.

Our commitment to building trust in open adoption means we prioritize transparency, honesty, and advocacy for birth mothers at every stage of the process.

Why So Many Birth Parents Feel Open Adoption Is Right for Them

Open adoption offers significant benefits for birth parents, adoptive parents, and children alike. Here's why so many birth mothers choose this path:

Ongoing connection: You don't have to say goodbye forever. Open adoption allows you to stay involved in your child's life, see them grow, and know they're thriving.

Peace of mind: Knowing who is raising your child and having the ability to check in can provide immense emotional relief.

Easier healing: Many birth mothers find that staying in contact helps them process their grief and maintain a sense of connection, rather than wondering and worrying. Birth mother counseling can also provide additional support during this time.

Benefit to the child: Research shows that children in open adoptions often have a stronger sense of identity and better emotional outcomes because they understand their story and have access to both families.

Of course, open adoption isn't right for everyone. Some birth mothers prefer more privacy or find that semi-open or closed adoptions better suit their needs. The key is choosing what feels right for you. To explore the pros and cons of open adoption, reach out to our team for personalized guidance.

Real Stories: Open Adoption from a Birth Mother's Perspective

Hearing from women who've been through the process can help you feel more confident in your decision. Caitlin's story demonstrates how open adoption relationships can evolve into something beautiful and lasting through American Adoptions:

"I was never sad about what had happened or anything like that — just that I wasn't going to be able to hold him and see him. They became my family. Knowing that I can be around and be there — I don't even know how to put it into words… I'm like a cheerleader on the sideline, and that's more than I could have asked for. He gets this family who can take care of him and do everything I couldn't, but he can also know that I didn't just give him away. I had a purpose for him, and it was meant to be."

Caitlin maintains regular contact with her son's adoptive family through texts, video chats, and updates, and considers them part of her extended family. She had nearly six months between her match and delivery to get to know the adoptive parents, Matt and Amanda, which helped build a strong foundation for their ongoing relationship.

You can read more birth mother testimonials on the American Adoptions website to hear from other women who've walked this path.

Start Your Open Adoption Journey with American Adoptions

Choosing adoption is never easy, but you don't have to navigate it alone. American Adoptions is here to support you with compassionate guidance, ethical practices, and a commitment to helping you create the future you want — for yourself and your child.

Whether you're still exploring your options or ready to take the next step, our team is here to answer your questions and provide the resources you need. Contact us today to learn more about how we can support you through an open adoption in Arkansas.

Disclaimer
Information available through these links is the sole property of the companies and organizations listed therein. American Adoptions provides this information as a courtesy and is in no way responsible for its content or accuracy.