close menu

Get Free Info

One More Time - How One Family Chose Our Agency for Their Second Journey

Lyndsey and Marie’s Story

American Adoptions wasn’t always on Lyndsey and Marie’s radar. In fact, for their first adoption four years ago, the couple worked with a smaller matching agency to bring home their daughter.

But, that first agency taught them a few important lessons when they were first-time adoptive parents. When they started talking about adopting again, they knew to think hard about finding a new professional. 

“We were pretty naïve at the time,” Lyndsey remembers. “Having now learned a lot more about adoption, we realized it was kind of unethical — my daughter’s birth mom did not have a lawyer, did not have a social worker, she wasn’t offered counseling. In hindsight, that was something we should have been thinking about, but we just didn’t know.” 

Lyndsey and Marie agreed they needed a full-service agency that could provide the services their daughter’s birth mother didn’t receive. It just so happened that a friend of theirs had adopted through American Adoptions. After talking to their friend and an adoption specialist, they knew it was the right choice for them.

“We just felt a lot more comfortable with the way American Adoptions supports expectant and birth mothers,” Lyndsey remembers.

Lyndsey and Marie will be the first to tell you that they got lucky with their adoption journeys. They waited only a few weeks to be chosen for each adoption opportunity and, save for some state-specific legal issues, their adoption processes were straightforward and successful.

“(Our story) was kind of unusual,” Lyndsey admits. “I don’t want people to have those kind of expectations, because it’s going to hurt a lot when you’re let down. It’s super unusual, we got super lucky, we don’t know why.”

But, that’s not to say there weren’t some difficulties — and some important learning experiences — along the way.

Adopting as a Lesbian Couple

When Lyndsey and Marie began their first adoption journey, they chose to work with a matching agency that specialized in adoptions by same-sex couples. Like all hopeful adoptive parents, the two were nervous about their chances of being chosen by a prospective birth mother, and being a same-sex couple added another degree to their concerns.

Their worries would turn out to be unfounded.

“Both of our kids’ birth moms specifically wanted lesbian couples,” Lyndsey says. “Our son’s birth mother is actually a lesbian herself, and her mom is too; [our son’s birth mother] was a donor baby. So, that made a lot of sense.”

In fact, Lyndsey said adopting as a lesbian couple through American Adoptions offered an advantage their last agency could not — the chance to stand out.

“People either are or aren’t going to adopt to gay people. There’s no ‘maybe,’” she adds. “I don’t know where people get that idea, or why they want to, or why there’s so many women who think, ‘Yeah, I want to adopt to a lesbian couple,’ but with American, there are a lot less couples to wade through.”

Managing Open Adoption Relationships

Today, Lyndsey and Marie have very open relationships with both of their children’s birth mothers — something they enjoy and specifically hoped for in their second adoption opportunity. As they prepared for their first adoption opportunity with their first agency, they also prepared for the opportunity of pre- and post-placement contact with expectant mothers.

Still, Lyndsey says it’s nothing you can really understand until you are living it. Fortunately, it’s been mostly smooth sailing on their part; they meet with their children’s birth mothers about once a year, and both children will play a role in their son’s birth mother’s wedding next year, too.

That’s not to say it’s always been easy.

“It hurts that our kids have three moms, but I think that’s every adoption — you’re not going to be the only mom,” Lyndsey says. “My daughter’s birth mom wants her to call her “Mommy ‘A.’ Of course, I’ll respect her wishes, but it hurts to hear it.”

Learning Along the Way

While Lyndsey and Marie’s children are still fairly young at this point, the couple is taking steps to prepare for the future. Lyndsey has joined a few adoption support groups, mainly those with adult adoptees, to anticipate the needs and feelings of her children in the years to come. She knows she will have to answer her children’s questions about why they were placed for adoption when their biological siblings were not, as well as other complicated situations specific to each child’s birth father.

Lyndsey and Marie have also made tough decisions when it comes to protecting their children’s best interests. Because they adopted transracially with their children, they made sure to join transracial adoption support groups to recognize their responsibilities as adoptive parents. Lyndsey is white and, even though Marie is Filipino, they’ve had a bit of learning curve when it comes to learning about anti-racism.

“I clearly have a lot to unpack,” Lyndsey says. “My tolerance is a lot lower, and my voice is a lot louder. I’ve lost a lot of family because I won’t tolerate jokes or micro-aggressions and they’re not willing to face their racism. We have one close white family member who suggested ‘Beaner’ as a cute nickname for my Mexican daughter and saw nothing wrong with that. My kids might not understand now, but they will someday, and we want our kids to know that their moms will always stand up for them and that they’re our first priority.”

Lyndsey says she has found herself in a guiding role for other adoptive parents, some of whom have reached out via their adoption agencies and others through their adoption support groups. While she’ll be the first to admit that she and her wife are learning this as they go, there’s one piece of advice she would pass along to other adoptive parents:

“The more honest you are in your profile, the better your whole experience will be,” she says. “Once you start lying and pretending you’re somebody you’re not, you’re going to deal with that for the rest of your life.”

Information available through these links is the sole property of the companies and organizations listed therein. American Adoptions provides this information as a courtesy and is in no way responsible for its content or accuracy.

Request Free Information

Join Us Now
Adoption Home Study

Adoption Home Study Process

Learn what a home study is and why you need one to adopt a child.

Read More

Home Study Questions and Answers

While adoption home studies vary slightly from agency to agency and state to state, there are several key elements that are almost always included in every home study.

Read More

Home Studies: State by State

Find a qualified professional in your state to complete your home study.

Read More
Frequently Asked Questions

Do we need to retain our own attorney?

No, American Adoptions has established relationships with some of the best adoption attorneys in the nation. Because adoption laws vary from state to state and between counties, it is important to utilize the services of an adoption attorney who specializes in the state where the adoption will finalize, which is unknown until you match with an expectant mother. You have the right to retain your own attorney, but doing so may be an additional, unnecessary expense.

Can we choose the gender of our baby?

American Adoptions does not allow gender specificity in adoption. Any family who wishes to be gender-specific in their adoption should contact us at 1-800-ADOPTION and ask about the possibility of an exception waiver before taking any other steps toward adoption with our agency. Any families who do receive an exception to be gender-specific may also incur an additional fee, which helps cover the additional advertising costs of such a request.

Please note that gender specificity will likely increase your wait time significantly.

Additional Resources

Adoption Newsletter

Did you know that American Adoptions offers a free bi-weekly e-newsletter? Sign up today to keep up-to-date on the latest in adoption news and information.

Sign Up

Famous Adoptions

Learn which famous Hollywood actors, sports stars, politicians and other icons have been touched by adoption.

Read More

Adoption Glossary

Do adoption terms and phrases leave you feeling confused? Learn the meaning to key adoption words and phrases with our comprehensive adoption glossary.

Read More