close menu

Get Free Info

Twins Is What They Do - One Family's Journey into Adopting Multiples

Dan, Dawn, Matthew, Lily and Amy's Story

High school sweethearts Dan and Dawn loved to travel and cherished the opportunity to expose their son Matthew to new places and experiences. But something was missing.

“I really just wanted to be a mom. Not that I wasn’t still a mom to Matthew, but I wanted him to experience having a baby in the house and loving another person in our family,” Dawn says.

Matthew, their first child, was long-awaited, and though Dawn and Dan pursued fertility treatments for a second child, they quickly turned to adoption to grow their family, calling the decision “amazingly easy.”

They came to American Adoptions at the recommendation of a friend when Matthew was 5 years old. After overcoming their reservations and coping with a wait time, Dan and Dawn were elated to receive a match call about a year after their activation: for a set of twins in Ohio.

After the twins were born, Dan and Dawn introduced them to Matthew and had custody of the infants for about a week when the call came. The birth father wanted to raise his children and had filed with the state to do so. This meant a custody battle ahead for Dan and Dawn and no promise that they would become the parents of the twins. Had the state not been behind on case files, Dan and Dawn might never have even made the trip to Ohio.

“I just couldn’t even talk,” Dawn says. “I was just clutching those babies and saying, ‘No, no, no.’ That was a bad moment.”

Dan asked for the twins to be picked up immediately, and the couple spent the summer healing from the adoption disruption. Eventually, with the support of family members and friends, Dan and Dawn put themselves back on the active list with American Adoptions.

“We had a little philosophy with our son. If he falls off his bike, you tell him to get back on, and it was a little of the same. We were all right. It was not ideal, but waiting didn’t make it any better. So, we signed back up,” Dan says.

The couple was especially relieved when Babies “R” Us graciously took back many of their baby items, some without boxes or receipts.

“Of course, we ended up needing it all three months later anyway,” Dawn says.

Another Chance

The first call came on a Sunday afternoon in August 2010 nearly three months after the first match. A pair of twin girls had been born in New York City. Dawn was dumbfounded.

“They told us this kind of thing could never happen,” she says.

But at nearly midnight that night, the birth mother specialist called back to say the birth parents changed their minds.

“I almost threw up,” Dawn says.

In the morning, Dawn drove Matthew to school and broke the news to him. The then seven-year-old realized the family might not get twins again, and exclaimed, “But, Mom, twins is what we do!”

Dawn promised they would still eventually adopt, “although we had toyed with the idea of taking twins off, since it was bad karma,” Dan says.

Later that Monday morning, Dawn was furniture shopping when their adoptive family specialist called later that Monday morning. She proceeded to tell Dawn that the twins’ parents continued to call American Adoptions.

“That never happens. Once they change their minds, they’re done,” she said, trying not to get Dawn’s hopes up but leaving the door open.

It wasn’t until Tuesday night that Dan and Dawn received the call that the adoption was official. The twins had been signed right over to them. Dan and Dawn carried their sleeping son to a neighbor’s house, packed until the wee hours of the night and hopped on a plane at 7 a.m. Wednesday. They spent the plane ride picking names for their daughters.

Starting a New Journey

When Dan and Dawn walked right into a bustling NICU in Jamaica, Queens, they first laid eyes on Lily, who was ready to be discharged. Amy, born smaller than her sister, stayed in the hospital for a couple of weeks. The hospital staff bundled Lily up in her car seat, gave the couple a quick run-down of the girls’ birth and medical history and briefly showed them Amy.

“We had like 10 minutes, and all of a sudden, we had a baby,” Dan says.

“We didn’t even hold her till we got back to the hotel because they put her in the car seat for us,” Dawn says, “and we’re sitting on the bed with the car seat, and we’re like, OK.”

Two weeks went by. Matthew flew to New York and was stunned at how small his baby sister Lily was. But the couple heard very little about Amy, who was still in the NICU. Finally, Amy was discharged on the Friday before Labor Day weekend amid the winds and rains brought by Hurricane Earl.

Dawn made a point to speak up at the hospital to learn how to breastfeed Amy but was pleasantly surprised when she took her bottle perfectly.

“She had this look on her face like, ‘Oh, there you are. I’ve been waiting for you,’” Dawn says.

Double Trouble

“Just managing the two at once, what a blessing,” Dawn says, “but what a handful.”

The couple learned that one person could feed both girls at once, but only if they were in their car seats. For those first couple months, Dan took the early night shift from 8 p.m. to 11 p.m. Meanwhile, Dawn, often going to bed before Matthew, took the late shift from midnight on.

Matthew bonded quickly with his sisters. Amy calls him “Bafoo” and claps when he enters the room. Lily points to his picture while he’s at school as if to say, “How soon is he going to get here?”

“He completely adores them,” Dawn says. “And they laugh at him all the time.”

Amy and Lily are Indian-American, which often prompts strangers to ask where Dan and Dawn got them. Though Dan and Dawn have been consumed with surviving the first year as parents to twins and a vivacious 8-year-old, they are looking forward to learning more about Indian culture together and have resources nearby in friends and neighbors.

Dan and Dawn never had the opportunity to meet Amy and Lily’s birth parents, who wanted a closed adoption. And though talking about the disruption still brings a quiver to Dawn’s voice, she  she’s glad she had the opportunity to meet the birth mother in their first match.

“I guess I wish I’d had the opportunity to tell our birth mother thank you, having seen our first birth mother Jane go through it,” Dawn says. “No matter how much you want the baby or don’t want the baby, it’s not an easy decision. When it came time to let go, it was so hard. I felt this kinship to her. And it was the happiest day for us, and it was the hardest day for her.

“I want the birth mothers out there to know that we love them so much. We wouldn’t have loved them more if I had carried them.”

*The names of the birth parents have been changed to maintain confidentiality.


Information available through these links is the sole property of the companies and organizations listed therein. American Adoptions provides this information as a courtesy and is in no way responsible for its content or accuracy.

Request Free Information

Join Us Now
Adoption Home Study

Adoption Home Study Process

Learn what a home study is and why you need one to adopt a child.

Read More

Home Study Questions and Answers

While adoption home studies vary slightly from agency to agency and state to state, there are several key elements that are almost always included in every home study.

Read More

Home Studies: State by State

Find a qualified professional in your state to complete your home study.

Read More
Frequently Asked Questions

Do we need to retain our own attorney?

No, American Adoptions has established relationships with some of the best adoption attorneys in the nation. Because adoption laws vary from state to state and between counties, it is important to utilize the services of an adoption attorney who specializes in the state where the adoption will finalize, which is unknown until you match with an expectant mother. You have the right to retain your own attorney, but doing so may be an additional, unnecessary expense.

Can we choose the gender of our baby?

American Adoptions does not allow gender specificity in adoption. Any family who wishes to be gender-specific in their adoption should contact us at 1-800-ADOPTION and ask about the possibility of an exception waiver before taking any other steps toward adoption with our agency. Any families who do receive an exception to be gender-specific may also incur an additional fee, which helps cover the additional advertising costs of such a request.

Please note that gender specificity will likely increase your wait time significantly.

Additional Resources

Adoption Newsletter

Did you know that American Adoptions offers a free bi-weekly e-newsletter? Sign up today to keep up-to-date on the latest in adoption news and information.

Sign Up

Famous Adoptions

Learn which famous Hollywood actors, sports stars, politicians and other icons have been touched by adoption.

Read More

Adoption Glossary

Do adoption terms and phrases leave you feeling confused? Learn the meaning to key adoption words and phrases with our comprehensive adoption glossary.

Read More