close menu

Get Free Info

"An Ideal Situation" - How One Family Found a Life-Changing Local Adoption Opportunity

When Cathy and Ray got the news they were chosen by a prospective birth family, Cathy vividly remembers waiting for the other shoe to drop — the catch to what seemed like a perfect adoption situation. 

Like many adoptive parents, they were worried about the potential “what-ifs”: complicated birth father situations, drug exposure, and relationships with the birth family. They were nervous that their first time being parents might be more complex than they imagined — as if choosing adoption after a few rounds of in vitro wasn’t already less than simple.

So, when Cathy found out that a local birth mother and birth father were choosing adoption together, wishing to have an open adoption, and had a healthy background, it seemed too good to be true.

“You go into it thinking that you’re going to have this complicated situation that will cause you heartbreak,” Cathy says. “I’m just glad that we didn’t let our fear of hardship get in the way of doing it, because we ended up having the easiest, best adoption you could ask for.”

Working with American Adoptions

Like many couples, Cathy and Ray had attempted multiple rounds of infertility treatments prior to choosing adoption. But, when they reached a crossroads in their treatment plan, they decided to look at all of their adoption options. They soon found that adoption was nothing like they had imagined.

“Like a lot of things when we started, we just made assumptions but, in doing it, we kind of realized that our assumptions were kind of off,” Cathy says. “Like, international adoption — I thought, ‘Okay, we need to get a baby from China,’ but, nope, I learned babies don’t come from China anymore. You think that open adoption — that doesn’t happen or it only happens in kinship adoptions. A lot of our assumptions are dated and misinformed.”

After debating between different kinds of adoption, Cathy and Ray settled on private domestic infant adoption because they wanted their first experience as parents to include every part of that unique journey. Cathy says she did extensive research to select an agency but choosing American Adoptions was a no-brainer for a few reasons.

“We chose American in large part because of the insurance policy, and then, secondarily, the number of placements,” Cathy remembers. “We were looking at agencies that were smaller and closer to us… but the fact that we could get a placement potentially between three and nine months — and it ended up being less than that — those were definitely motivating factors.”

Their waiting period may have been shorter than they imagined, but that’s not to say that their time spent preparing for it was easy. While Cathy says the easiest part of the process was creating their family profile, when it came to filling out their Adoption Planning Questionnaire, the couple had to think hard about what they were open to in a potential adoption situation. They spoke at length to their adoption specialist and did extensive research before settling on preferences they were comfortable with but wouldn’t impact their wait time too much.

When it came down to it, the worry was for naught. They were informed about a match opportunity just a few weeks after going active.

Finding the “Ideal Situation”

After receiving “the call,” Cathy and Ray were excited and nervous about the opportunity to get to know the prospective birth parents. A young couple who were pregnant with their first child, the birth parents lived in the same state as Cathy and Ray — and were excited to form an open adoption relationship with their child’s potential parents. Cathy describes their first call as similar to a blind date — but, again, they would find the nerves were unfounded.

“We hit it off right away,” Cathy remembers. “Every time I talk to them, I like them even more. When we went to meet them, we ended up going to a Dave & Buster’s, so it was a good, interactive fun thing to do. My husband and I are both in our late thirties, and they’re in their late teens, so it was like, ‘What do I have in common with someone who is basically a generation younger than me?’

“We had similar senses of humor… and I genuinely feel like we would be friends if it weren’t for the adoption,” she says.

The proximity between the two families did more than impact their open adoption relationship; it made the logistics of the adoption even easier, especially when it came time for the birth mother to deliver. Cathy and Ray were able to be at the hospital when their son was born and share in those special moments with the birth parents. Cathy says she recognizes how rare and amazing it was to share the moment with the baby’s birth father, too.

“One nurse, on the way out, said, ‘I’ve been doing this for 15 years, and I’ve never seen a situation like this. I’ve seen adoption every once in a while, but I’ve never seen where everyone genuinely cares about the baby — where there’s that much love in the room,’” Cathy remembers.

Keeping in Touch

Saying “goodbye,” as temporary as it would be with their open adoption, was still an emotional rollercoaster — one which Cathy says she’s not sure she could have ever fully prepared for.

“[It’s more] emotionally exhausting than I could have imagined,” she remembers. “You’re overjoyed, but you can’t be happy because they’re sad, and you’re also sad for them, so you feel bad — I’ve never felt so wonderful and so awful at the same time.”

Their open adoption relationship certainly helps. It’s now been a few months since baby Ray was adopted, and Cathy says she talks on the phone with the birth parents and sends them pictures frequently. In fact, the birth parents recently came to visit their son. Cathy says she and her husband recognize the beauty of their situation and let the birth parents set the tone with communication.

“We get a lot of weird looks from people when we say it’s an open adoption, and that we’re close to the birth parents,” she says. “People are like, ‘What are you doing? Is that okay? Is that normal?’ Yeah, why wouldn’t it be?

“An open adoption isn’t necessarily a back door for the birth parents to come back and take their baby; it’s just more people to love your kid, that’s kind of how I see it. Don’t be afraid of open; it can be awesome.”

Looking back now, Cathy knows that she and her husband were spoiled with their first adoption experience — but they certainly wouldn’t have it any other way.

“It’s like the movie ‘Juno,’ which, incidentally, I named my horse after that movie — so, you know, it was just something that was meant to be,” she laughs.


Information available through these links is the sole property of the companies and organizations listed therein. American Adoptions provides this information as a courtesy and is in no way responsible for its content or accuracy.

Request Free Information

Join Us Now
Adoption Home Study

Adoption Home Study Process

Learn what a home study is and why you need one to adopt a child.

Read More

Home Study Questions and Answers

While adoption home studies vary slightly from agency to agency and state to state, there are several key elements that are almost always included in every home study.

Read More

Home Studies: State by State

Find a qualified professional in your state to complete your home study.

Read More
Frequently Asked Questions

Do we need to retain our own attorney?

No, American Adoptions has established relationships with some of the best adoption attorneys in the nation. Because adoption laws vary from state to state and between counties, it is important to utilize the services of an adoption attorney who specializes in the state where the adoption will finalize, which is unknown until you match with an expectant mother. You have the right to retain your own attorney, but doing so may be an additional, unnecessary expense.

Can we choose the gender of our baby?

American Adoptions does not allow gender specificity in adoption. Any family who wishes to be gender-specific in their adoption should contact us at 1-800-ADOPTION and ask about the possibility of an exception waiver before taking any other steps toward adoption with our agency. Any families who do receive an exception to be gender-specific may also incur an additional fee, which helps cover the additional advertising costs of such a request.

Please note that gender specificity will likely increase your wait time significantly.

Additional Resources

Adoption Newsletter

Did you know that American Adoptions offers a free bi-weekly e-newsletter? Sign up today to keep up-to-date on the latest in adoption news and information.

Sign Up

Famous Adoptions

Learn which famous Hollywood actors, sports stars, politicians and other icons have been touched by adoption.

Read More

Adoption Glossary

Do adoption terms and phrases leave you feeling confused? Learn the meaning to key adoption words and phrases with our comprehensive adoption glossary.

Read More